For years, Body Mass Index (BMI) has been treated as a gold standard in determining health risk. From insurance eligibility to clinical diagnoses, it’s everywhere. But as Brandy W. Root, RDN, highlights in her powerful commentary, BMI often misleads more than it informs—especially for women.

The Gender Gap in BMI Relevance

BMI was based on the measurements of European men in the 19th century and has never been restructured to reflect biological or physiological diversity—particularly among women. This foundational bias results in skewed assessments that can mislabel healthy women as overweight or obese, especially those with naturally higher fat distribution due to hormonal and reproductive factors.

1. Body Composition and Fat Distribution

Women naturally carry more body fat than men, particularly in the hips, thighs, and buttocks—a pattern known as gynoid obesity or “pear-shaped” fat distribution. Research shows this distribution may protect against metabolic conditions like cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes. Yet, women with this healthy fat pattern are still often flagged as at-risk solely due to their BMI.

In contrast, android obesity, characterized by fat around the abdomen (more common in men), poses greater health risks. BMI doesn’t differentiate between the two, placing both body types in the same category—masking actual risk profiles and leading to misdirected interventions.

2. Reproductive Life Stages and Weight Fluctuations

Women’s bodies undergo significant physiological changes throughout life—puberty, pregnancy, postpartum recovery, perimenopause, and menopause. Each stage affects weight, metabolism, and fat distribution. BMI fails to account for these transitions, often penalizing normal biological processes.

For example, postpartum women frequently experience long-lasting changes in body shape and composition. However, they are still measured by static BMI standards, which can cause unwarranted stress, stigma, or recommendations to lose weight despite a healthy recovery trajectory.

3. Mental Health and Weight Bias

BMI-related stigma disproportionately affects women. In many clinical and coaching settings, a high BMI becomes a proxy for poor health, leading to a focus on weight loss rather than strength, wellness, or disease prevention. This often results in disordered eating, body dissatisfaction, and reduced trust in healthcare providers.

Root points out the pressure women face to meet a “normal” BMI, often driven by their desire to please their providers, even if it means chasing an unrealistic weight goal. As practitioners and coaches, we must challenge the cultural narrative that equates thinness with health and instead support functional, individualized outcomes.

A Holistic Approach for Women’s Health

Women deserve a broader, evidence-based lens that considers their full health profile:

• Encourage strength-building: Muscle mass is especially important for women entering midlife and beyond. Focus on resistance training and protein intake—not just scale weight.

• Track meaningful markers: Look at lipid profiles, blood pressure, sleep quality, energy levels, and mood. Ask how their clothes fit, not just what the number says.

• Support cyclical changes: Respect fluctuations related to menstrual cycles, pregnancy, and menopause.

• Prioritize mental and emotional well-being: Celebrate non-scale victories and body diversity.

Inner Circle (Includes BA, OMM)

Platinum Business Packages

Done-for-you programs

📚 Further Reading & Resources

Limitations of BMI for Women

• Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
  Highlights how BMI fails to account for factors like fat distribution, muscle mass, and metabolic health, leading to potential misclassifications, particularly in women. ​Harvard Public Health

• Verywell Health: BMI Chart for Women of All Ages
  Discusses how BMI does not consider age, sex, or body composition, which can result in misleading health assessments for women. ​Verywell Health

Alternative Measures to BMI

• National Institutes of Health (NIH): Assessing Your Weight and Health Risk
  Provides information on waist circumference and waist-to-hip ratio as better indicators of health risks associated with body fat distribution. ​

• Scientific American: Better Ways Than BMI to Measure Obesity
  Explores methods like DEXA scans and body composition analyses that offer more precise assessments of body fat and health risks. ​Scientific American

The Obesity Paradox in Older Adults

• The Times: Older People ‘Should Be Told to Maintain a Buffer Weight’
  Discusses the concept that a higher BMI in older adults may be protective against certain health risks, challenging traditional BMI interpretations. Latest news & breaking headlines​

• PubMed Central: The Obesity Paradox and Mortality in Older Adults
  A systematic review examining how overweight and obesity might be associated with lower mortality in certain older populations. PMC​

Professional Guidelines and Statements

• American Medical Association (AMA): Use of BMI Alone is an Imperfect Clinical Measure
  Acknowledges the limitations of BMI and recommends incorporating additional measures for a more accurate health assessment. American Medical Association​

• National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI): Assessing Your Weight and Health Risk
  Offers comprehensive guidelines on evaluating weight and associated health risks beyond BMI. NHLBI, NIH